
When did you last read a privacy policy before tapping accept?
One of the first things they teach you in medical school is that a signature is not consent.
Before any procedure, a doctor has to sit with the patient and explain what will be done, what could go wrong, and what the other options are.
Then you ask the patient to tell you, in their own words, what they’ve understood. If they can’t, you explain it again.
I stopped practising medicine years ago to build startups, but that rule has stayed with me. A patient has to know what they’re agreeing to, or the form means nothing.
Last week I downloaded a new app. Before it let me in, it showed me two links, Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, and one box to tick.
I didn’t open either. I ticked the box in about two seconds.
If a patient had signed a consent form that way, no doctor I trained with would have gone ahead. On my own phone, I didn’t think twice.
So I went looking for how often we do this, and why.
98% agreed to give up their first-born child
In a study published in 2018, two researchers, Jonathan Obar and Anne Oeldorf-Hirsch, asked 543 undergraduate students to sign up for a social network called NameDrop. The researchers had made it up.
Students could read the privacy policy first, or press “quick join” and skip it. Around 74% pressed quick join.
Even the ones who opened the privacy policy spent about 73 seconds on it.
On paper, every one of them had agreed. In a hospital, not one of those signatures would have counted.
We read when we can see the cost
Most of us aren’t careless.
We notice a ₹40 delivery fee. We read ten reviews before buying ₹1,500 earphones.

It’s spread across dozens of apps. It shows up months later. Often it lands on someone else.
So the ₹40 fee gets our attention, and the contacts permission doesn’t.
Reading properly isn’t realistic either.
In 2008, Aleecia McDonald and Lorrie Cranor at Carnegie Mellon worked out that reading every privacy policy a typical American came across would take 244 hours a year.
That’s about 30 full working days a year, just reading.
A patient about to have surgery can feel what’s at stake. Someone opening an app can’t.
So the patient listens, and the rest of us tap.
India has already seen what uninformed consent costs
A few years ago, instant loan apps were everywhere. Many asked for access to the phone’s contacts, and people tapped allow without a second thought.
When borrowers fell behind, recovery agents used those contacts. They called friends, relatives and bosses to shame people into paying.
In 2020, a borrower in Telangana told The News Minute that his lender had made over 200 calls to people in his phone. It told them he had given their names as references for the loan. He hadn’t.
The people being called had never agreed to anything. Someone else had tapped " Allow " for them.
Researchers have a name for this.
They called it interdependent privacy. Your privacy doesn’t just depend on what you do. It depends on what everyone who has your number does.
In 2022, the RBI had to step in. Regulated lenders’ apps could no longer read your contacts, call logs or photos, and recovery agents were told to leave your family and friends alone.
One rule did what millions of careful taps never could.
A better box to tick
On 13 November, one part of India’s new data protection rules switched on. Companies can now apply through a registration portal to become “consent managers”: a single place where you give, check and take back consent, instead of hunting through each app’s settings.
A consent manager can’t read the data that passes through it.
That’s useful. But it’s a better place to tick the box. It doesn’t explain what’s inside it.
India already has something like this for money. Account Aggregators pass your financial data to lenders with your permission.
Yet in a 2024 survey, only 32% of smartphone users had even heard of them.
The rest of the rules, including fines of up to ₹250 crore for breaches caused by weak security, kick in from May 2027.
No fine can make anyone understand what they never read.
What I would do this week
Use the test every doctor is taught before a procedure.
Open the settings of the five apps you use most and look at what each one can access: contacts, location, camera, microphone, photos.

Start with contacts. That’s the one where you’re agreeing on behalf of everyone saved in your phone, and none of them were asked.
A patient gets a full conversation before they sign anything. The least we can do for our own phones is ten minutes and one question.
Hit reply and tell me: which app had access to something you couldn’t explain?
I read every email.
Until next week,
Ritesh
P.S. Most phones have one screen, under Privacy, that lists every app allowed to use your contacts, camera, microphone or location. It’s the fastest audit you’ll do all year.




